Performing this exercise on gut-feel alone and no prior guidance provides a starting baseline from which students can trace the evolution of their ethical decision making.

A suggestion: Have students count off 1-5.

Have all the respective students with the same number regroup.

Assign each of the 5 scenarios to the respective groups.

Give the students 10-15 minutes to work individually in order to answer their respective scenario.

Then ask the students to form 3-5 person small groups among students with like numbers.

Give 15-20 minutes for them to formulate a group answer.